- Recently I read this joke, not sure where, which said that the American and Indian middle classes are feeling sad that they cannot take part in a revolution, unlike their counterparts in Egypt, Tunisia, Libya, Yemen and other similar place. Instead, they can only vote
- There needs to be some sort of an antitrust law for political parties. There is currently little to distinguish between the policies of various political parties. For example, all parties favour a greater role for the government (more govt => more opportunity to make money on the side => more corruption, etc.) .
- Given the homogeneity in the political spectrum, there is little incentive to vote. This scoundrel may be only marginally better than that scoundrel, so why bother voting. So we have this large middle class which essentially removes itself from the political process (confession: I’m 28, and I’ve never voted. When my name’s in the list I’ve not been in town, and vice versa.)
- Now this Anna Hazare tamasha has suddenly woken up people who never bothered to vote, and who are pained with excessive corruption. So they’re all jumping behind him, knowing that this gives them the opportunity to “do something” – something other than something as bland and simple as voting.
- Supporters of Hazare care little about the implications of what they’re asking for. “Extra constitutional bodies”? “Eminent citizens”? Magsaysay award winners? Have you heard of the National Advisory Council? You seriously think you want more such institutions?
- The Lok Ayukta isn’t as useless an institution as some critics have pointed out. But then again, this is highly personality-dependent. So you have a good person as a “lok pal”, you can get good results. But what if the government decides to appoint a compliant scoundrel there? Have the protesters considered that?
- Basically when you design institutions, especially government institutions, you need to take care to build it in such a way that it’s not personality-dependent. Remember that you can have at TN Seshan as Election Commissioner, but you can also have a Navin Chawla.
- So when you go out in droves and protest, you need to be careful what you ask for. Just make sure you understand that.
5 thoughts on “Something’s Itching”
This kind of voting removes the kind of arbitrary appointments taht you are talking about.
Must admit I too got caught up in the emotionality and vociferous rallying behind what Anna Hazare has stirred up. We Indians love getting involved in drama no! Tough one though. Someone needs to moderate this better so that things are not rushed or decisions are not influenced by people who don’t really understand. And as I type this, twitter tells me there’s a new Anna Hazare fan page.
The “Hazare” coterie have removed the Nobel Prize Winners & Magsaysay Award Winners clause – http://indiaagainstcorruption.org/docs/Jan%20lokpal%20bill%202.1.doc
Thanks for the links. Very useful.
I have been examinating out a few of your stories and i can state pretty clever stuff. I will surely bookmark your site.